If you're a Houston homeowner looking for help protesting your HCAD appraisal, you've probably come across several firms. Most charge 25% to 50% of your savings, and some work across several states. We're PropTaxLab, a protest firm that started in Houston and now files in 16 Texas appraisal districts. We built this comparison because we believe informed homeowners make better decisions. Here's how we stack up.
The comparison at a glance
| What you get | Typical Large Firm | Mid-Size Firm | PropTaxLab |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rate | ~30-40% (varies) | 25% | 20% |
| Geographic focus | Statewide or national | Varies | 16 Texas appraisal districts |
| Services offered | Residential, commercial, multiple services | Property tax + other services | Property tax protests — that's it |
| DIY option | No | No | $199 Evidence Pack |
| See your evidence? | Not typically shared | Limited visibility | Full report shared |
| Free value check | Varies | Varies | Yes, for anyone who asks |
| Cancelling | Check agreement | Check agreement | Anytime, in your portal or by email |
| Cost-to-cure analysis | Not typically | Not typically | Included |
| No savings, no fee | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Why rate matters more than you think
On a $3,000 annual tax savings, here's what you actually keep with each firm:
| Firm | Rate | Their Take | You Keep |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical large firm | ~30-40% (estimated) | $900 – $1,200 | $1,800 – $2,100 |
| Mid-size firm | 25% | $750 | $2,250 |
| PropTaxLab | 20% | $600 | $2,400 |
| PropTaxLab Evidence Pack | $199 a year | $199 | $2,801 |
On $3,000 of savings, that 5 to 20 point difference is $150 to $600 more in your pocket each year it happens. Over five years of savings like that, going from a 40% firm to PropTaxLab at 20% keeps about $3,000 more. It adds up.
Why focus matters
Most large firms operate across multiple states and handle residential, commercial, and other property types. Your Houston HCAD protest is one of thousands of things they're managing across the country.
PropTaxLab does one thing: property tax protests for Texas homeowners, and Harris County is where we started. That means our team is looking at Houston comps daily, understands HCAD's micro-market neighborhoods, and builds evidence packages specifically for how HCAD appraisers evaluate protests. Focus is what lets us show you every piece of evidence we file.
The do-it-yourself option
Many firms offer full service or nothing. If you'd rather file yourself but want professional evidence, that leaves you on your own. PropTaxLab's Evidence Pack fills that gap — for $199 you get a complete copy-paste package with your recommended value, pre-written iSettle comments, a professional evidence package, and step-by-step instructions. You file it yourself in 10 minutes and keep all but $199 of your savings.
This is ideal for homeowners who don't want to pay 20-40% of their savings for full service but also don't have 5-10 hours to research comps themselves.
Transparency
One of the most common complaints about larger protest firms — visible in online reviews and BBB complaints — is that homeowners never see the evidence used in their protest. They don't know what comps were submitted, what value was recommended, or how the negotiation went. They just get a result and a bill.
At PropTaxLab, every customer — both Full Service and Evidence Pack — receives a full copy of the evidence package used in their protest. You see every comp, every equity analysis, every market data point. It's your property. You should know what's being said about it.
Our honest assessment
We're obviously biased — we built PropTaxLab because we thought Houston homeowners deserved a better option. But here's when each firm might be the right choice:
Choose a large firm if: you own commercial property or need cost segregation services. Multi-property, multi-type capabilities can be useful for complex portfolios.
Choose a multi-service firm if: you want a single platform that also handles insurance and utility bills, and you value the convenience of bundling services.
Choose PropTaxLab if: you want a 20% rate, to see every piece of evidence we file, and the option to file yourself with professional support.