The short answer: it depends on how far your appraisal is above what your home would sell for. At Harris County's roughly 2.3% combined tax rate, every $10,000 the district takes off your value saves about $230 a year. A 5% cut on a $400,000 home is about $460; on a $900,000 home with no homestead cap, it's over $1,000. Homes in neighborhoods where HCAD raised values aggressively tend to have the most room.
Why are the savings so large? Because Harris County has some of the highest property tax rates in the entire country — roughly 2.1% for a Houston home, about twice the U.S. average. That means every $10,000 in assessed value costs you about $210 a year, and a $100,000 reduction saves about $2,100 a year.
The math: a Houston example
Say HCAD appraises your home at $950,000. You protest and get the value reduced to $795,000 — a $155,000 reduction (including cost-to-cure deductions for property issues). At Harris County's combined tax rate of approximately 2.32%, here's what happens:
Tax savings that year: $3,596. (This example has no homestead cap. With one, the savings depend on how far the value drops below your capped value.) The district reappraises every year, so next year's value starts fresh.
That saving is spread across every taxing unit on your bill (school district, county, city, MUD), because they all tax the same appraised value. A lower HCAD value lowers what you owe each of them.
What does it cost to protest?
| Method | Cost | You Keep (on $3,596 savings) |
|---|---|---|
| DIY (do it yourself) | Free + 5-10 hours of research | $3,596 |
| PropTaxLab Evidence Pack | $199 flat | $3,397 |
| PropTaxLab Full Service | 20% of savings | $2,877 |
| Typical other firm | 25% to 50% of savings | $1,798 – $2,697 |
Every option saves you money. The question is how much time you want to invest and how much of the savings you want to keep. One often-overlooked factor: listing property issues (old roof, dated kitchen, foundation problems) can add more through cost-to-cure deductions, something not every firm includes.
Is it worth it?
At every price point, yes. Filing a protest is free, and protests very rarely raise a home's value, so the downside is small. The only cost is your time (if DIY) or a modest fee (if using a service).
Even at a 20% contingency fee, you keep 80% of what's saved. And with the $199 Evidence Pack, a $1,000 saving is a 5x return; if you save less than $199, we refund the difference.
What affects how much you save?
Your home's value matters. A 10% reduction on a $600,000 home saves about $1,392/year. The same 10% on a $900,000 home saves $2,088/year. Higher-value homes have more to gain.
How far HCAD's value is above market matters. If HCAD is close to market value, you might get a 3-5% reduction. If they're way off, you could get 10-15% or more. Neighborhoods where HCAD raised values aggressively tend to see the biggest reductions.
Your evidence matters. Homeowners who bring organized, data-driven evidence — comparable sales, equity analysis, photos of condition issues — consistently get better results than those who show up with general complaints. The quality of your case directly impacts the size of your reduction.
What if I don't save anything?
It happens occasionally, usually when HCAD's assessment was already in line with market conditions. If you use PropTaxLab's Full Service, you owe nothing — our fee is 20% of savings, so zero savings means zero fee. If you bought the Evidence Pack and saved less than $199, we refund the difference — you never lose money.
The protest itself carries very little risk: protests very rarely raise a home's value. The usual worst case is that your value stays the same, which is where you'd be if you didn't protest at all.